I went through the whole thread and dld everything you mentioned. I have 12 albums to go through at this point. WIsh it was easier to digest, sucks when I can tell I don't dislike it. Yet can't figure out if I like it or not.
By the way, while reading I noticed I never answered your Atheist question. I gave it a couple listens when it came out and deleted it. I was planning on dling it again in the future.
Only Atheist album I own is Unquestionable Presence. Which is a really fun listen, good album.
I'd rank em as such.
Another note, I love Jupiter's album cover. Amazing piece of art. That artist is phenomenal, same dude who did Sodom's War and Pieces. Great album covers.
Piece of time (I think I listened to it once and deleted, so it might be unfair.)